Head to the Barn Mission
- Head to the barn at the end of the property.
- Open the door.
- Beat the O’Driscoll in a fist fight.
- Question the O’Driscoll 2 times.
- Choice: Spare the man or choke him to death.
- Pick up your gun and your hat.
- Pet the horse to calm it down.
- Lead the horse out of the barn.
- Approach Dutch.
- Head back inside the house.
5. Choose to Kill or Spare the O’Driscoll
You will be given a choice to choke the O’Driscoll to death or spare his life. Choosing any of them has no difference so this is all down to preference.
Red Dead Redemption 2 Head to the barn quest is done.